How NaviModel handles theoretical uncertainty of subsea sensor spreads
What is TPU, TVU and THU?
- TVU (Total Vertical Uncertainty, ie the Z/height value)
- THU (Total Horizontal Uncertainty, ie the XY value)
- calculating an estimated error budget up front (called a priori, since the method involved making predictions beforehand) based on sensor specification and precision.
- calculating the total theoretical propagated error/uncertainty of the combined sensor setup. Several articles describe this topic, including Error budget analysis for hydrographic survey systems… by Geraud Naankeu Wati. This article points out that the appropriate algorithms handle many factors, including the precision of individual sensors, their mounting/calibration precision and their timing as well as data algorithms such as beam forming, ray bending, etc.
(Click to enlarge) Elements of the propagated error/uncertainty calculation
With NaviModel 4.2, we'll implement two new approaches that focus on planning and estimating the TPU:
- Planning: This theoretical approach carries out a TPU calculation, used prior to a survey for overall error budget estimation based on estimated depth, and therefore is used to check (for example) which parts of the sonar data fall within customer requirements.
- Real estimation: This approach calculates the TPU on all sonar soundings after the data is acquired. In others words, the uncertainty estimate is available for each ping.
Let’s look at the two features in more detail:
Overall error budget on a system (planning)
When estimating the precision/uncertainty of a specific sensor setup, a number of tools are available. With these tools all known parameters for the individual sensors as well as formulas for the sensor internals such as ray bending, travel times etc can be manipulated to model the sensor uncertainty as accurately as possible. The uncertainty of multi-beam echo sounders (MBEs) is especially tricky to define – and is sometimes kept a bit of a secret by the manufacturers. NaviModel of course offers a standard equation based on pulse length, travel time, frequency, etc, all of which can be optimised by adding extra information into the user-defined equations.
NaviModel links to the NaviEdit database (the NaviSuite product for survey data editing) and uses the entire sensor configuration, the C-O and the latency, and stores user-defined sensor uncertainty for future use together with the data.
A number of graph views are available, making it very easy to see if a certain sensor configuration will meet customer specifications. The survey uncertainty level can be compared with IHO levels or self-defined criteria.
(Click to enlarge) TPU calculation based on a Reson 7K survey setup
Uncertainty on each sonar sounding (real estimation)
The sensor uncertainty parameters that are used during planning are also used to calculate the uncertainty on all pings in real time during acquisition. The result is available as a NaviModel colour mode. That is, the values can be used to colour the DTM based on the uncertainty level of the data.
(Click to enlarge) Colouring the DTM according to the level of uncertainty of the raw data
It is also possible to analyse the individual swathes and how they match specifications.
(Click to enlarge) Scan-by-scan view of the TVU
All the TPU (TVU/THU) values of a survey are available for use in custom surface models and are used in specific surface/cleaning algorithms such as the CHRT (CUBE V2) (more on this later on).
Would you like to hear more about how NaviModel handles theoretical uncertainties?
We’ll cover this topic with a presentation and demonstration during EIVA Days Denmark 2017 on 13 September and EIVA Day Scotland 2017 on 20 September in Aberdeen – you are of course also welcome to reach out to us if you have any questions.
Trends in the maritime survey and engineering industry: Number 5 – Deep learning technology
The technological development of the maritime industry is moving faster than ever. Staying ahead and thus ensuOctober 19 - 2017
New cleaning option excels in not just 2D but also 3D sonar and laser data
Sonar and laser data can include a relatively high level of noise. A wide selection of data cleaning tools isOctober 11 - 2017
Expanding the payload of the ScanFish ROTV sensor platform by 700%
The EIVA ScanFish remotely operated towed vehicle (ROTV) is designed to function as platform for subsea sensorOctober 6 - 2017